You might think that nothing in this world is free, and sometimes, it certainly feels that way. Yet, there are ways to reduce charges if you’re careful and assess your options. That’s true when it comes to interchange fees, sometimes known as ‘merchant swipe fees.’ To give you an idea of the scale of these, US credit card companies earned $148.5 billion from interchange/merchant swipe fees in 2024. It’s a huge amount, and a chunk of that came from your business.
The good news is you can reduce your payment processing costs with some strategic moves. For instance, exploring interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing could be a way to reduce fees and keep cash in your bank account. At PayCompass, we’re serious about helping you reduce costs and grow your business, so let’s dive in and learn more.
TL;DR
- Interchange plus pricing offers the most transparency and typically lowest costs for businesses processing over $10,000 monthly.
- Flat rate pricing provides predictable costs but usually charges more overall to cover expensive premium card transactions.
- Tiered pricing creates complexity without clear benefits and often results in higher-than-expected costs.
- Your processing volume, transaction mix, and tolerance for complexity should drive your pricing model decision.
- High-volume merchants benefit most from interchange plus, while new or low-volume businesses might prefer flat rate simplicity.
Understanding Interchange Plus Pricing: The Transparent Choice
Before we jump in, let’s talk about what interchange fees are and why you need to pay them. Basically, interchange fees are set by major card networks, such as Visa and Mastercard. They’re non-negotiable, so you can’t actually get out of paying them, but you can explore different pricing routes to cut the amount if you’re eligible. As a business, these fees allow you to accept electronic payments quickly and safely.
Exploring interchange plus pricing vs tiered pricing simply means you’re finding the best way to pay these fees for your business. For some, a flat rate works out best. For others, tiered pricing is a cheaper option over the long-run. Learning how all the options work helps you find the best fit for your needs.
How Interchange Plus Actually Works
If you choose interchange plus pricing, every transaction consists of an interchange fee (non-negotiable) and your processor’s fixed markup. This varies according to the card type used, the transaction method, and the merchant category. For that reason, some transactions cost more than others.
It might seem complicated initially, but once you get used to it, it’s quite straightforward. The processor markup remains the same depending on the processor you use. This is a small percentage of the transaction, plus a fixed fee. It varies from processor to processor, but generally falls between 0.25% to 0.50% and then a per transaction fee of around 0.25%. This remains the same no matter what type of payment method your customer uses. It’s the interchange fee part that fluctuates.
Why Your Costs Change Month to Month
The reason your transaction costs may fluctuate is down to the different card types. These all have different interchange rates. For instance, premium reward cards tend to cost more to process than standard debit cards, so interchange fees here are higher.
Yet, the major advantage here is that with interchange plus pricing, you’re paying real costs based on your transaction amounts. You’re not paying an average rate that might not actually reflect the transaction mix you’re processing. It’s a ‘pay for what you use’ situation.
The Transparency Advantage
In the interchange plus vs flat rate debate, another plus point is transparency. With interchange plus pricing, you can look at your statements and audit them without issues. You’ll easily understand why some transactions cost more than others. You can then approach your processor and negotiate the markup completely independently from the non-negotiable interchange fees. This could reduce the amount you pay over the long-term.
Overall, interchange plus pricing allows you to make informed decisions and lays everything out clearly on your merchant statement.
When Interchange Plus Makes Perfect Sense
Like all pricing models, interchange plus may work for you, or it may not. The key is to understand which category you fall into.
In general, interchange plus works well for established businesses that have a consistent processing volume. If cost transparency is important to you, this pricing model is worth exploring. Additionally, if you’re happy to accept changing monthly costs for lower fees over the long-term, interchange plus could be for you.
At PayCompass, we’re keen to help you explore different pricing models, helping you decide whether interchange plus will work for you or not. Our helpful experts can look at different options and work with you to find the best fit.
Volume Requirements That Matter
In most cases, businesses that process more than $10,000 per month see the most significant benefits. The reason is because the cost savings then outweigh the added complexity of a variable pricing structure. Transparency is also key here, particularly as your transaction volume increases.
On the other hand, if your business processes lower volumes, you might not see dramatic cost savings, but transparency is still a benefit.
Industry-Specific Benefits
There are some industries that find interchange plus pricing a good option in particular. For instance, B2B companies and e-commerce businesses. The main reason is down to a range of transaction types. In this case, you’ll pay for what you actually process and not a general average which might leave you at a loss.
Evaluating If Interchange Plus Works for You
In our bid to compare interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing, let’s now sum everything up and see whether interchange plus is for you. The table below outlines everything you need to know.
| Monthly Processing Volume | Recommended Pricing Model | Expected Savings with Interchange Plus | Complexity Level |
| Under $5,000 | Flat Rate | 0.10% – 0.30% | Low benefit vs. complexity |
| $5,000 – $15,000 | Evaluate Both | 0.20% – 0.50% | Moderate analysis required |
| $15,000 – $50,000 | Interchange Plus | 0.30% – 0.70% | High benefit, manageable complexity |
| Over $50,000 | Interchange Plus | 0.40% – 0.80% | Maximum savings potential |
Your Statement Analysis Process
The first place to start is with your processing statements over the last three to six months. From there, look for your average effective rate, monthly volumes, and transaction types. This will give you a good starting point to see whether interchange plus could help you save on fees.
To find your current effective rate, you simply take your total processing fees and divide them by your total processing volume.
Comparing Processor Markups
Earlier, we mentioned that different payment processors have varying markup rates. So, when you’re making a decision, ask for quotes from several processors with regards to markups. Then, compare these to find the best fit. Remember, at PayCompass, our rates are competitive and we have no hidden fees – what you see is what you pay.
Flat Rate Pricing: Simple but Costly
Now, let’s compare interchange plus vs flat rate with what we’ve learned so far.
To break it down, flat rate pricing means you pay one rate for every transaction. It doesn’t matter what card type or transaction method is used, the rate remains the same. The main benefit is immediately obvious – it’s predictable and simple. However, it’s not all positive because it can result in higher costs over time for some businesses. With everything, it’s important to assess whether this pricing method suits your needs.
The Appeal of Simplicity
Let’s talk about the most obvious benefit – simplicity. With flat rate pricing, you don’t have to look at any variables or categories; you know exactly what you’ll pay. As a result, it’s much easier to budget and it cuts out any surprises.
Predictable Monthly Expenses
Because you know the percentage charge you’ll pay for all transactions regardless of the card type, your cash flow planning is easier. In this case, flat rate pricing is a good fit for businesses that have tight margins and a need for predictable costs. With this type, your profit margins will remain consistent and it’s much easier to plan.
This predictability means your accounting and bookkeeping becomes simpler too. You don’t have to complicate matters by categorizing your transaction types; you simply have one consistent expense.
No Unpleasant Rate Surprises
We’ve already mentioned the lack of surprises, and this is the major benefit of flat rate pricing. Even if you’re in the middle of a quiet or busy season, your charges remain the same.
For instance, if you opt for interchange plus pricing and you go through a high season, you might see an increase in your processing costs. However, flat rate avoids this.
The Hidden Costs of Flat Rate Pricing
While flat rate pricing is simple, it isn’t without its downsides. In some cases, it won’t help you reduce credit card processing fees and could even work out more expensive depending on your transaction volume.
For processors to make a profit, they need to set their prices high enough to cover expensive premium card payments. So, you’ll pay more on low cost transaction types that, with interchange plus pricing, would be cheaper.
Limited Cost Optimization Options
Unlike interchange plus pricing, you can’t put any strategies into place to reduce costs. You can’t encourage your customers to use a lower-cost payment method because they’re all priced the same.
Ultimately, you’re stuck with the same rate and can’t make any moves to lower it. So, it’s important to explore the trade off between this and simplicity.
When Flat Rate Pricing Makes Sense
Just like with interchange plus, flat rate pricing is a good fit for specific types of businesses. In most cases, new businesses, and those with low processing volumes will find flat rate works for them.
Perfect for New Business Owners
Let’s quickly explore why new businesses benefit from flat rate pricing. It really comes down to simplicity, particularly while still setting up their business operations. This form of pricing is much easier to understand. It also doesn’t require you to have a strong payment processing knowledge base. With predictable costs, you can start your initial business planning and establish your cash flow without any unwelcome surprises.
Let’s be honest, at the start point of any business, everything is complicated enough. You really don’t need to add anything extra.
Low-Volume Merchant Benefits
When comparing interchange plus vs flat rate, we also need to talk about low-volume businesses. If you process less than $5,000 per month, flat rate pricing will probably work out cheaper and easier for you.
In most cases, low-volume businesses don’t normally have a dedicated accounting team to deal with complex processing statements. So, choosing flat rate pricing cuts down on the administrative side of things too.
Tiered Pricing: The Complicated Middle Ground
We’ve talked about two of the main pricing groups, and next, let’s take a look at tiered vs interchange plus and fixed rate. Remember, if all of this sounds complicated right now, don’t worry. At PayCompass, our experts are waiting to answer all your questions and help you find the right fit for your business. After all, we focus on a personalized approach – your business isn’t the same as anyone else’s.
With tiered pricing, different card types and transaction methods are grouped into pre-defined categories. Each tier has a different rate. While relatively easy to control cost-wide, it does have some benefits and challenges. For one, it’s a little more complex than flat-rate pricing.
Understanding the Three-Tier Structure
In most cases, tiered pricing uses qualified, mid-qualified, and non-qualified categories. Within this, rates increase as transactions move into tiers with higher risk or higher cost. It sounds simple, but it can sometimes be difficult to predict which group your transactions end up in. Qualification rules can also be quite complex at first.
Qualified Tier: The Advertised Rate
The lowest advertised rate is normally the qualified tier. This often includes basic debit and credit card transactions. Yet, the rate usually represents only half of a business’ transaction volume. In that case, the advertised rate can be quite misleading.
The reason is because transactions have to meet set criteria, and this varies from processor to processor. Some common criteria include swiped payments, whether it’s a standard consumer card (not premium), and whether proper authorization procedures were followed. If one criteria isn’t met, the transaction moves into a higher tier, and it will cost you more.
Mid-Qualified: The Hidden Costs
The middle tier includes rewards and business cards, as well as any transactions that missed data from the previous tier. The difference between the basic rate and this one is anywhere between 0.50-1.00% of the base qualified rate.
Rewards cards almost always fall into this category. It doesn’t matter how they were processed, including cashback cards and airline miles cards. Many customers prefer to use these because of the rewards, but they cost you more. Alongside this, we have business cards. So, if your business falls into the B2B category, many of your transactions will fall into this mid-qualified tier.
Non-Qualified: The Penalty Tier
The top tier is where premium cards usually end up. Alongside this, manually keyed transactions, or those that should be mid-tier but missed information, end up here. This tier has an increase of 2-3% from the mid-qualified stage, significantly affecting your processing costs.
Why Tiered Pricing Creates Problems
You can clearly see the differences in complexity between interchange plus vs tiered pricing, along with a lack of transparency. It can be very hard to predict and then optimize your costs. Alongside this, some processors can tweak tier qualifications without actually changing their advertised rates, so you still end up paying more.
Unpredictable Qualification Rules
As we’ve explored, it’s not possible to predict where your transaction will fall. This makes budgeting very difficult, and you can’t put cost management strategies into place. Qualification rules are very complex and vary between processors, and they can change them with little to no notice.
Comprehensive Pricing Model Comparison
Interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing shows major differences between all types. Choosing the one that suits you best can be difficult, but that’s where an understanding and knowledgeable processor comes in useful. At PayCompass, we’re not going to push you into any specific route that doesn’t suit you best. Instead, we’ll talk to you and give you your options, helping you decide the most optimal choice.
Decision Framework for Choosing Your Pricing Model
When choosing your pricing model, it’s important to take several things into account. These include your processing volume, transaction mix, and whether you’re happy to deal with extra complexity. Also think about your long-term business goals, because you want your pricing model to scale with your plans.
In most cases, volume plays the biggest role in your choice. If you’re a high-volume business, interchange plus pricing will probably suit you best. If you’re a low-volume business, flat rate might work out better for you. Yet, it’s rarely that straightforward. There may be many other variables that you want to take into account, and that’s something that PayCompass’ experts can help you with.
Transaction Mix Analysis
If you process many different payment types, particularly diverse cards, interchange plus could be a good route. This offers transparency over how much you’ll pay. However, if your transaction patterns are pretty consistent, explore flat-rate or tiered pricing.
If you’re an e-commerce business, interchange plus pricing is probably for you. This is because you’ll process many card-not-present payments, and this model will help you optimize costs.
Growth Considerations
What if your business is growing fast? In that case, you need to look for a model that scales well with increased volume. The best answer is usually interchange plus pricing, as this will suit you better over the long-term. If you get locked into a flat-rate pricing model at this point, it will be far more costly as you grow.
However, it may be that you need to think about switching models at some point in the future. That’s why you also need to look at the costs involved in this before you make any decision. Some processors enforce termination fees, or they ask you to sign a long-term contract. In that case, switching models later on will be very expensive.
To break everything down, let’s compare interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing in the table below.
| Feature | Interchange Plus | Flat Rate | Tiered |
| Transparency | Highest – Shows actual costs | Medium – Simple but opaque | Lowest – Complex qualification rules |
| Cost Predictability | Low – Varies by transaction | Highest – Same rate always | Medium – Depends on tier mix |
| Overall Cost | Lowest for most merchants | Highest but predictable | Variable, often higher than expected |
| Setup Complexity | Medium – Requires understanding | Lowest – Simple to implement | High – Must understand tier rules |
| Best For | Established, high-volume businesses | New/small businesses, simplicity seekers | Rarely recommended |
| Monthly Volume Sweet Spot | >$10,000 | <$5,000 | No clear advantage |
| Statement Complexity | High – Detailed breakdown | Low – Simple summary | Medium – Tier categorization |
| Optimization Potential | High – Can influence costs | None – Fixed rates | Limited – Tier manipulation possible |
How PayCompass Simplifies Your Pricing Decision
We’ve talked a lot about interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing, and it’s clear that the decision can be complex. That’s why we’re here. At PayCompass, we help break down the complicated side of payment processing and make it easier for you to understand.
We don’t believe that you should need a degree in finance to understand payment processing. You really just need to know your business and use available information to find a route forward that serves it best. Rather than pushing you into an expensive and confusing arrangement, we work with you to find a suitable route.
Our fees are competitive and transparent. We don’t hide anything; we’d rather guide you toward a route that actually helps you run your business in a most cost-effective way. This also supports your growth plans.
So, whether you’re unsure which way to turn, or you’re looking for the cheapest payment processing possible, we’re here to give you expert guidance.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the best pricing model can feel like a complicated math problem. And it’s true that it’s one of the most important financial-related decisions you’ll make for your business moving forward. It doesn’t only affect how much money you make, but how smooth your business runs.
Remember, there are three main models to choose from – interchange plus vs flat rate vs tiered pricing. Interchange plus is a good choice for established businesses, and it’s transparent too. Yet, it won’t be the right option for all. Then, we have flat-rate pricing, which, as the name suggests, gives you a predictable and simple route. But what about when your transactions don’t quite fall into the ‘simple’ category? You might end up paying more. And that leaves us with tiered pricing. This is when different transactions fall into specific groups and are priced accordingly. However, the qualification criteria for each tier can be complex. If you miss one small detail, you end up in the higher price tier.
Making the best choice for your business shouldn’t be a snap decision. It’s something you need time to consider, analysing your transaction history to find what fits. And, of course, you need guidance. That’s where PayCompass comes in. Reach out today and our experts can help you explore your options. We don’t push you toward the most profitable route for us; instead, we focus on helping you find the best choice for you and you alone. Let’s work together and form a payment processing partnership that helps you grow now and in the future.
Ready to Transform the Way You Do Business?
Don’t settle for less when it comes to payment processing. With PayCompass, you get smarter, faster, and more reliable solutions tailored to your unique needs. Join thousands of businesses who trust us to keep their business moving forward.
Similar Posts
Finding the Right Merchant Account for High Chargeback Payment Processing
If you have a high chargeback rate, many traditional merchant account providers won’t want to work with you. Chargebacks involve extensive investigations and are costly for payment processors, which is why they often entail additional fees and expenses. As a result, many payment processors are unwilling to take on the added risk. At PayCompass, we […]
Using Venmo for Business: What I Learned After Testing It for My Small Business
Sending money isn’t a particularly difficult subject these days. After all, there are many different payment methods and platforms you can use to send money from place to place. Yet, the difficulty comes from finding the right one for your needs, particularly if it’s a business payment. The choice can be overwhelming, especially when you […]
Virtual Cards for Travel Agency Operations: The Complete Payment Revolution You’ve Been Waiting For
If there’s one industry that deals with countless vendors, it’s certainly the travel industry. Flight companies, hotels, tour operators, the list goes on. Of course, it’s vital to protect your cash flow as just one blip could throw your payments completely out of whack. That’s where virtual cards for travel agency use come in very […]
Seasonal Payment Processing: Why Your Peak Season Success Depends on Getting This Right
For some businesses, sales aren’t steady across the year. Instead, they peak and trough depending on the month, season, and event. In those cases, everything needs to run as smoothly as possible to avoid major hiccups. After all, you don’t want your payment systems to crash during Black Friday sales, do you? In these cases, having […]
High Volume Merchant Accounts: Why Your Business Needs More Than Basic Payment Processing
Every business is different. You can have two companies that sell the same thing, but their sales volume and how they go about their business will be completely different. And that’s a good thing – after all, variety is the spice of life. Yet when it comes to payment processing, it’s important to find a […]
Travel Industry Chargebacks: The Hidden Revenue Killer Destroying Your OTA’s Bottom Line
The travel agency has long been one of the most profitable around, but there’s no denying that it faces challenges. Not only are many popular destinations mostly seasonal, it also got hit very hard by the COVID-19 pandemic. The other issue? It’s classified as a high-risk industry, which means there are hurdles and challenges awaiting […]
Pre-Authorized Payments: Full Guide
As the name suggests, a pre-authorized payment is when a customer gives you permission to automatically charge them for their goods or services. For companies, this type of approach is a convenient way to ensure a steady cash flow. When bills are due, your administrative staff members don’t have to chase anyone for their monthly […]
What Is ACH Fraud and How To Prevent It
Automated Clearing House (ACH) payments are governed by Nacha. When a payment is made, it moves through the ACH network until it reaches the recipient. This type of payment is typically used for direct deposit, automated bill payments, peer-to-peer transfers, and payments to contractors. While the ACH network is extremely secure, ACH fraud can easily […]
Merchant Discount Rate (MDR): Full Guide
If you’ve ever read through your merchant account statement, you’ve likely noticed that the entirety of your company’s transactions doesn’t end up in your bank account. Instead, a merchant discount rate (MDR) is pulled from the payments before the final amount is transferred into your merchant account. To maintain your company’s profitability, it’s essential to […]
22 Best High-Risk Merchant Account Providers for 2025
Normally, companies process transactions in their merchant accounts. However, payment processing carries risks for the payment processors. Because of this, many merchant account providers do not want to work with a company that has a higher risk profile. If your business has had a high rate of chargebacks or fraudulent transactions, you may struggle to […]